| Who pays you today? | Yahoo Scout | ProRata itself, from its own products | Perplexity itself, from subscriptions | No licensee named | No licensee announced | ProRata, as a test | The National Library: NOK 45 million a year | TNO, from GPT-NL license revenue; no paying licensee shown | No one: no collective runs on FORA yet |
| Which uses do you license, and who picks them? | Every AI use in each license; you can exclude a licensee or a section | Answers; no training; fixed | Pays on visits, citations and agent actions; choice not stated | Training; you opt into the license | You pick: training or retrieval | Retrieval; you opt in per deal | Training only; fixed | Training only; fixed | You pick, per term; a pool leaves training out |
| Who picks whose content gets used, and is the method published? | The AI company; method not published | ProRata's own engine; method not published | Perplexity's own engine; method not published | The AI company, from content it already buys; method not stated | You choose what to offer; the AI company's pick is not stated | ProRata's engine, in the test; DPCMO's documents don't say | The National Library "shall determine which publications are used"; method not published | You choose what to contribute; TNO filters and weights it for training, by a published rule | The operator's search; the ranking rule is the operator's own, and it can publish it |
| Who counts the use your share rests on? | The AI company, in its own report | ProRata's attribution engine | Perplexity | Not stated for AI; licensee surveys in CCC's other licenses | Not stated for AI; licensee reports, audits and surveys in CLA's other licenses | ProRata's attribution engine | No one: a lump sum | TNO, once: your tokens in the training set, and their quality | Signed fetch records, with AI companies' reports checked against them |
| Is the split rule published? | Principles; the calculations "are not publicly disclosed" | The formula, not the attribution weights | Three categories of traffic | No | General splits; no AI rule yet | Not online | General guidelines; the split among newspapers not found | Yes, in TNO's template: token count times a quality multiplier | Every weight and threshold |
| What does the operator keep? | Its costs, "projected at or below 10%" | 50% | "a small portion"; 20% in press reports | Not published | 11% (CLA) and 6% (PLS) on standard licenses; not stated for AI | Not published | Not published for this money | 50%, re-invested in the model | The operator sets it, and publishes it |
| Is it regulated, and do members vote? | Not regulated; no member vote; a publisher steering committee | A private company; no vote | A private company; no vote found | Not regulated; no vote found | Regulated; publishers vote through trade associations | Regulated; members vote | Regulated; member organizations vote | Not regulated; no direct vote; a contributors' Content Board | Not regulated; each operator sets its governance |
| Does it reach copies an AI company took before any license? | Yes | No: retrieval only | Not stated | Not stated | No: "No retrospective cover" | No; DPCMO is suing OpenAI over it | The library's own collections, yes; earlier training of its base models, no | No: it covers GPT-NL's own training only | No: a copy already held leaves no record to check |